Bug #14905: DHCP reservation for PXE boot not added when using static boot mode - Foreman

Custom queries

3.11.5 release DONE
3.11.5 release TODO
3.12.2 release DONE
3.12.2 release TODO
3.13.0 release DONE
3.13.0 release TODO
All bugs by votes
All issues closed in the last 3 weeks
Easy and Trivial Issues
Easy Issues (only)
Foreman - new open issues in last 10 days
Good first issues - Foreman core
high prio open bugs
Host registration [open]
Mine
My issues closed in the last 3 weeks
old bugs
Open with target version set (aka blockers)
registration
taken-none
Team Atlas untriaged bugs
templates
Trivial Issues
Untriaged and opened in the past two weeks

Actions

Copy link

Bug #14905

closed

DHCP reservation for PXE boot not added when using static boot mode

Added by Jan-Otto Kröpke over 8 years ago. Updated over 6 years ago.

Status:

Closed

Priority:

High

Assignee:

Dominic Cleal

Category:

DHCP

Target version:

1.11.3

Difficulty:

Triaged:

Bugzilla link:

1340167

Pull request:

https://github.com/theforeman/foreman/pull/3552

Fixed in Releases:

Found in Releases:

Red Hat JIRA:

Description

Hi,

we have one central tftp server and multiple dhcp servers to avoid the dhcp relay via firewalls.

Since foreman 1.11, we can not deploy vm, because foreman will not add the dhcp leases on the external dhcp servers. PXE will not work anymore.

tcpdump also wont show any connections..

If I add a tftp role to a dhcp server and attach it to one subnet, the leases will be added to this dhcp server doing the host creation and everything will be work as expected.

I can not find any errory on /var/log/foreman-proxy/proxy.log or /var/log/foreman/production.log .

Best Regards,
Jan-Otto Kröpke
noris network AG

Files

Bildschirmfoto 2016-05-02 um 19.00.51.png	View Bildschirmfoto 2016-05-02 um 19.00.51.png	33 KB		Jan-Otto Kröpke, 05/02/2016 01:01 PM
Bildschirmfoto 2016-05-02 um 19.02.05.png	View Bildschirmfoto 2016-05-02 um 19.02.05.png	25.9 KB		Jan-Otto Kröpke, 05/02/2016 01:02 PM

Related issues 2 (0 open — 2 closed)

	Related to Foreman - Bug #14113: DHCP orchestration ignored subnet bootmode	Closed	Marek Hulán	03/09/2016			Actions
	Related to Foreman - Support #14792: foreman not sending the POST to the DHCP smart proxy	Resolved		04/24/2016			Actions

Issue # Delay: days Cancel

History
Notes
Property changes
Associated revisions

Actions

Copy link Download all files

Updated by Jan-Otto Kröpke over 8 years ago

File Bildschirmfoto 2016-05-02 um 19.00.51.png Bildschirmfoto 2016-05-02 um 19.00.51.png added
File Bildschirmfoto 2016-05-02 um 19.02.05.png Bildschirmfoto 2016-05-02 um 19.02.05.png added

I have attached two screenshot

One from installing a machine.

An another screenshot from the subnet setting.

As you can see, the step "configure dhcp" is missing on the first screen.

Looks like foreman ignore the settings from the subnet.

Unset and set the settings again does not work correctly.

We are upgrade to foreman 1.11 and then to 1.11.1. Maybe there are some migrations issues.

Actions

Copy link

Updated by Dominic Cleal over 8 years ago

Project changed from Smart Proxy to Foreman
Category changed from DHCP to DHCP
Status changed from New to Need more information

What is the Boot mode set to in the Subnet settings? Ensure it's on DHCP, not Static.

Actions

Copy link

Updated by Jan-Otto Kröpke over 8 years ago

It is Static and it work since 1.6 without any problems.

The subnet which has the foreman as TFTP and DHCP proxy itself,

If Static is a problem, how to deploy PXE machines?

Actions

Copy link

Updated by Dominic Cleal over 8 years ago

Related to Bug #14113: DHCP orchestration ignored subnet bootmode added

Actions

Copy link

Updated by Dominic Cleal over 8 years ago

Status changed from Need more information to Feedback

It is Static and it work since 1.6 without any problems.

The linked bug changes behaviour to only create DHCP reservations when DHCP boot mode is in use. You should consider changing the boot mode to DHCP, which should fix PXE booting.

Actions

Copy link

Updated by Jan-Otto Kröpke over 8 years ago

Its does not make sense.

PXE should work even with Static Boot mode. In my opinion, provision and boot mode are two different things.

Using DHCP as boot mode is fatal, because if the foreman is unavailable, all maschine will drop the ip after the lease time..

The Foreman will mutate to a single point of failure.

Actions

Copy link

Updated by Dominic Cleal over 8 years ago

Subject changed from Foreman does not add dhcp.leases for new vm, if dhcp and tftp proxy is different to DHCP reservation for PXE boot not added when using static boot mode
Status changed from Feedback to New

PXE should work even with Static Boot mode. In my opinion, provision and boot mode are two different things.

Yes, I'll leave this bug open for that reason.

Using DHCP as boot mode is fatal, because if the foreman is unavailable, all maschine will drop the ip after the lease time..

As an aside, DHCP is provided by your DHCP server and not Foreman, so could well be set up in a failover or other HA configuration.

Actions

Copy link

Updated by Jan-Otto Kröpke over 8 years ago

Thanks.

Maybe a configable option would be the best.

Actions

Copy link

Updated by Daniel Gagnon over 8 years ago

I confirm hitting the same issue.

In our setup, we are using DHCP for provisionning, but static IP addressing for the servers once they are online.

We still want the lease to be created to support the provisionning process as well as recovery environnements.

Actions

Copy link

#10

Updated by Dominic Cleal over 8 years ago

Translation missing: en.field_release set to 155

Actions

Copy link

#11

Updated by Dominic Cleal over 8 years ago

Translation missing: en.field_release changed from 155 to 159

Actions

Copy link

#12

Updated by Baptiste Agasse over 8 years ago

I confirm too, we use dhcp server only in "static" mode. The dhcp server is only used for provisioning purposes (DHCP/PXE/TFTP) and keep track of already assigned IPs on our subnets with dhcp reservations.

Actions

Copy link

#13